Friday, September 23, 2005

The walls we put up are not sukkat shalom

I finished reading the recently published biography of R. Saul Lieberman. It not only gives a fascinating view on R. Lieberman, but also sheds light on how the denominations of Judaism view themselves and others. R. Lieberman from the outset had impeccible credentials, went to Yeshiva at Slobodka, studied at a Mussar Yeshiva , was the cousin of the Chazon Ish, and came from a distinguished line of rabbonim. However, there also were aspects of what he did that put him "outside the club" or cast doubt in some people's eyes about his "kashrut." R. Ruderman(of Ner Yisrael fame), a classmate at Slobodka, noted that R. Liberman was suspect even back then because he went to movies and read books. Others, like R. Kamenetsky, admired him tremendously for his learning.

R. Lieberman tried going to medical school in France, but wound up in Israel, and learned and taught at Hebrew U., where he was exposed to "critical methods of scholarship"- in other words, how to approach Shas not just from the point of view of the Rishonim and commentators, but looking at the text and the history and the context. However, he maintained that the text of Shas was something to be learned, not a corpse to be dissected. He published his first studies of Yerushalmi, and since Hebrew U. would not hire him full time, looked around for other employment and was offered a job at JTS. Others who were considered for that job were RYBS, and R. Belkin.

R. Lieberman viewed the position at JTS as an opportunity to study, since he only had to teach 6 hours a week, and also a way to influence the American rabbinate. At the time, R. Louis Ginsburg and R. Finklestein, the heads of JTS, viewed the institution as traditional, aligned with the orthodox in opposing the changes introduced by the reform. In fact, later they tried to have a joint bet din with the RCA(they also tried to have one with the reform rabbis) but it fell through when the RA(conservative rabbis) refused to be bound by the decisions, and R. Lieberman didn't want to force the issue.

R. Lieberman did not view himself as the halachic decisor for the conservative movement. More telling, he viewed himself as trying to keep the rabbis as traditional as possible and influencing them as much as possible to stay on "the path." All agree that personally his shmirat mitzvot was impeccable. His religious influence lasted only until his death, and obviously we have seen JTS and the Conservative movement move to the left, until sometimes it is hard to distinguish Conservative from reform at times.

In summary: He had yichus, went to impeccable yeshivot, was a genius and wrote brilliantly, was personally shomer mitzvot, tried to keep JTS traditional and yet, there are those who would not put a R. in front of his name, or put his books in a brown wrapper to study from them. And apparently(I dont know if this is true) a major publishing house wont even allow his name in its books.

Worse, it appears that there was an opportunity for intellect-based traditional judaism(my substitute for what would pass as modern orthodox) to flourish. After all, how much difference was there really in the approaches of R. Lieberman, R. Ginsburg, RYBS, or R. Belkin? Couldn't they have all worked together, instead of having been pulled to extremes? Or at least have their legacies claimed by those who are more to one side or another? It was very interesting reading the introduction written by the present chancellor of JTS. Obviously, someone who does not have the same Hashkafa as R. Lieberman did. He does all sorts of gymnastics to cast R. Lieberman in a more liberal light, which is clearly not accurate at all.

So now, we have a small part of the what used to be the Conservative movement, the true heirs of R. Lieberman, the UTJ(Union for Traditional Judaism) on one side, and the dwindling masses of Conservative Jews heading leftwards at an increasing pace(it seems that gay/lesbian ordination is on the horizon)on the other. On the orthodox side, we dont seem to have a true heir to RYBS(R. Aharon is probably closest in intellect and learning), but a group holding down the more liberal end(Edah, Chovevei Torah) and a group moving rightwards(rest of the YU world).

The sad part is that when you put a label on someone or some group, like Conservative, or Orthodox, people automatically make assumptions about what you do, and decide whether to affiliate or invite you to things, based on that label. If R. Lieberman had taught at any other school(except obviously the reform seminary), he would not have been denigrated by those termed orthodox. Similarly, RYBS would have commanded a lot more respect in the "yeshiva" world, if he had taught at a different school. Neither would have had to say a thing different, do a thing different, just have a different address and title. Interestingly, those who had an open mind and were scholarly enough to recognize genius and erudition, usually held both of those rabbis in great respect, regardless of the affiliation, but usually were not able to publically express it because of the political ramifications.

Worst, we continue to have these artifical walls and continue to make decisions on who to listen to and who not to, just based on an address. And this goes both for the right and the left, selective hearing has no prediliction for sides.

Comments-[ comments.]

23 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

"So now, we have a small part of the what used to be the Conservative movement, the true heirs of R. Lieberman, the UTJ(Union for Traditional Judaism) on one side...."

I respectfully suggest that the above should be rephrased:

"So now, we have a small part of what used to be a miniscule part of the Conservative movement as a whole but of a somewhat larger part of its JTS seminary..."
(Although the next part of the quote "the true heirs of R. Lieberman also isn't really correct, as I don't think that
Rabbi Lieberman ever considered himself part of that movement but only as a professor at JTS.)

I think that from about 1902-4 (the reorganization of JTS and the appointment of Solomon Schecter) onwards that JTS and the newly formed Conservative Movement was not on a path of Jewish tradition. Certainly when Kaplan who had already a bit earlier come out as an agnostic but was hired by JTS in the late twenties it was clear that JTS was not a place of traditional orthodoxy and the fact that Louis Ginzberg had to fight with the synagogue rabbis to maintain an official policy of halachic observance was also indicative of the wishes of the majority of that group.

3:29 AM  
Blogger Mississippi Fred MacDowell said...

>the cousin of the Chazon Ish

And a grandson (through marriage) of the Netziv.

12:47 PM  
Blogger AMSHINOVER said...

what is the name of the biography Saul Lieberman?
where can i find it?
please dont say it's this
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0773472436/qid=1128105722/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8_xs_ap_i1_xgl14/104-2075120-5673521?v=glance&s=books&n=507846

2:42 PM  
Blogger Steve Austin said...

Nice blog. Please check out my debt consolidation solution blog. It is all about debt consolidation solution.

6:58 PM  
Blogger business said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a debt management credit counseling
site/blog. It pretty much covers debt management credit counseling
related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

12:59 AM  
Blogger billuk said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a bankruptcy record
site/blog. It pretty much covers bankruptcy record
related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

11:41 AM  
Blogger dilbert said...

The name of the book is Saul Lieberman: the man and his work, and can be found here:






http://www6.mailordercentral.com/shopjts/prodinfo.asp?number=SL&variation=&aitem=56&mitem=74

or go to the JTS website and follow the links to JTS press

8:55 AM  
Blogger credit6sec said...

great content!
Visit my site too, relating to debt consolidation versus debt negotiation site. It deals with debt consolidation versus debt negotiation and other related stuff. Check it out if you get time :-)

10:52 PM  
Blogger heropoo said...

Help! I am lost. I was searching for bad debt credit card and somehow ended up here. How that happened I don't know, however I do like your Blog a lot. Would you mind if I add your Blog to my favorites page so others can visit?

3:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your message on consolidation is great! I have a site on bill consolidate counseling credit
Your readers might find interesting. You can check it out at: http://www.apexconsolidation.com

2:33 AM  
Blogger startonline said...

Cool blog you have about free credit card. I have a free credit card related site. Check it out if you get a chance.

8:08 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

affiliate cash earn program is great

i found here searching for the word affiliate cash earn program and your site was listed high on the word affiliate cash earn program
GOOD JOB

affiliate cash earn program

12:29 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

affiliate sales is great

i found here searching for the word affiliate sales and your site was listed high on the word affiliate sales
GOOD JOB

affiliate sales

12:29 PM  
Blogger Johnjon said...

Wow, I really like this one. I have a website that talks mostly about internet marketing company affiliate You should check it out sometime.

1:11 AM  
Blogger Johnjon said...

I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about affiliate affiliate marketing related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.

1:11 AM  
Blogger harvey said...

Blogarama that is good stuff nice one I have a blog too also I have a website dedicated to helping people with their debts, mortgages,student loans plus much more all FREE info consolidation debt free iowa services Take a look around it may help you in some way consolidation debt free iowa services

1:19 PM  
Blogger Charlie said...

Hi,
Do think you could get a banker's desire to force money into your laps?

houston car finance enligtens about houston car finance

8:06 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

personal debt consolidation will help you get out of debt forever! personal debt consolidation personal debt consolidation

8:16 PM  
Blogger Charlie said...

Hi,
Do think you could get a banker's desire to force money into your laps?

household finance enligtens about household finance

8:47 PM  
Blogger blaze said...

I found your site on card chase.com credit quite useful. I also have a site about card chase.com credit that you may find useful also. Please feel free to check it out and let me know what you think

7:02 AM  
Blogger De Post Man said...

Nice posts. Check out my site http://mortgage.27days27gurus.com/ if you get a chance. calculator mortgage rate

5:44 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

credit debt consolidation will help you get out of debt forever! credit debt consolidation credit debt consolidation

10:49 AM  
Blogger rebecca said...

Welcome to usfine for runescape gold service.

4:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home


Web Counter by TrafficFile.com Site Meter Add http://houseofhock.blogspot.com to your Kinja digest